Contracts vs. Agreements: Understanding the Key Differences

The terms "contract" and "agreement" are often used interchangeably in everyday business dealings. However, there are some notable legal distinctions between the two. 

Understanding the nuances helps ensure you pick the right legal instrument for a given business circumstance and structure optimal enforceable terms.

This comprehensive guide compares contracts and agreements, analyzing their technical definitions, key elements, legal enforceability, standards of proof, and common examples of each in commercial transactions.

Introduction

Understanding the Basics

Ever wondered why some people use the terms "agreement" and "contract" interchangeably? Well, you're not alone. But here's the thing: while they seem similar, they're different beasts altogether. Let's embark on a journey to explore these differences.

Why the Distinction Matters

A simple handshake or a nod might be considered an agreement, but does it have the same weight as a signed piece of paper? Stick around, and you'll find out.

What is a Contract?

Definition

Contracts are agreements with specific terms, and crucially, they are enforceable by law. Think of them as an agreement's big brother.

Constituent Elements

For a contract to be valid, it requires an offer and acceptance, consideration, the intention to create legal relations, and legal capacity. Quite a list, huh?

Types of Contracts

From express to implied, written to oral, bilateral to unilateral—contracts have several types. But one thing's for sure: they mean business.

A contract is a legally enforceable promise between two or more competent parties, where each party gives consideration to create a legal duty between themselves. Key attributes:

•  Legally binding and enforceable in court
•  Requires mutual assent to particular terms
•  Involves consideration or value exchange 
•  Creates defined rights and duties
•  Gives remedies like damages if breached

Contracts provide a legally recognized framework for business dealings and market exchange of goods, services, property, and more. Let's contrast them with agreements.

What is an Agreement?

Definition

At its core, an agreement is when two or more parties come to a common understanding about an issue. Sounds simple, right?

Key Elements

For an agreement, there's usually an offer, and acceptance, and a mutual understanding. Remember the handshake? That's your mutual understanding right there.

Informal vs. Formal Agreements

You and your friend agreeing to meet up for coffee? Informal. Renting a place and signing a lease? That’s inching towards the formal side, my friend.

The technical definition of an agreement is simply a mutual understanding between two or more parties regarding their relative intentions and actions. Compared to contracts:

•  Not necessarily legally enforceable
•  More informal and simpler construction
•  Do not require consideration 
•  Used more loosely in commercial dealings
•  Dispute resolution depends more on continued consent 

So the core distinction is enforceability. While all contracts are agreements, not all agreements rise to the level of legally enforceable contracts.

( Read our informative article on Guide on Legal Contacts & Agreements for Entrepreneurs )

Key Elements of a Valid Contract 

For a contract to be legally binding and enforceable, certain elements are required:

Offer and Acceptance - There must be mutual consent to the contract terms through an offer made and accepted.

Consideration - Something of legal value must be exchanged between the parties.

Contractual Capacity - The parties must be legally competent to enter a contract. Those severely mentally incapacitated or minors generally do not have contractual capacity.

Lawful Object - The purpose of the contract must be legal. Contracts cannot require illegal acts.

Genuine Assent - The agreement must be voluntary without coercion, undue influence or misrepresentation.

Simple agreements or informal promises generally do not meet all these requirements to be enforceable as binding contracts.

What Makes an Agreement Legally Enforceable?

For an agreement between parties to cross into the realm of legal enforceability, these key attributes are required:

•  Mutual intent to be bound by the terms
•  Offer, acceptance, and consideration
•  No defect in contract formation like incapacity or duress
•  Terms are sufficiently clear and complete 
•  The agreement is executed in proper contract form. 

Meeting these criteria distinguishes enforceable contracts from looser agreements or "gentlemen's agreements". Formality equals enforceability.

Key Differences Between Agreements and Contracts

Legality

While all contracts are agreements, not all agreements are contracts. The latter only enters the legal realm when it satisfies certain conditions.

Enforceability

Agreements might be morally binding, but contracts? They bring the power of the law with them.

Formality

Agreements can be as casual as they come, while contracts usually have a certain decorum.

Implications

Misunderstand an agreement, and you might lose a friend. Breach a contract, and you might find yourself in a courtroom.

Statute of Frauds - When Written Contracts are Required

 

An important concept in distinguishing enforceable contracts is the “Statute of Frauds”. Under this statute, certain types of agreements must be in writing to be legally binding, including:

•  Real estate purchase/lease contracts exceeding one year
•  Service contracts lasting longer than one year 
•  Contracts for sale of goods over $500 
•  Contracts that cannot be performed within one year of formation
•  Promises to pay the debt of another person 

If contracts falling into these categories are solely verbal, they will not hold up in court. The Statute of Frauds highlights the formality required for enforceable deals.

Standards of Proof in Contract Disputes

Another key distinction is the level of proof required if the validity or terms of an agreement are disputed:

Contracts - Enforceability is determined by courts based on evidence of required contractual elements like offer/acceptance and consideration. Courts utilize the “preponderance of the evidence” standard in most civil contract disputes, meaning the plaintiff must show their version of the facts is more likely than not true based on the evidence.

  

Agreements - Without documentation, it becomes challenging to prove loose agreements lacking contractual formalities. Courts would expect “clear and convincing” evidence the parties intended to be bound. The burden of proof for the plaintiff is higher.

This higher standard of proof is why written contracts far surpass verbal agreements.

Key Differences in Enforceability and Remedies

Due to different levels of formality and proof, key distinctions arise in enforcing contracts versus agreements:

Contracts

•  Enforceable through the court system if breached
•  Allows recovery of monetary damages from breaching parties
•  Rights to specific performance or full completion of duties
•  Parties can invoke termination clauses for breach
•  Protections like voiding contracts signed under duress

Agreements 

•  Often rely on continued mutual consent rather than judicial enforcement
•  Damages much harder to substantiate
•  Specific performance is unlikely if contested 
•  Limited protections against peer pressure to fulfill informal promises
•  No defined termination process. Renegotiation may be required.

The judicial system provides powerful remedies to enforce contractual rights that agreements lack.

Why does it Matter?

Business Implications

For businesses, understanding these nuances can be the difference between a successful deal and a lawsuit.

Personal Transactions

Ever heard of people being cheated out of their money? Knowing the difference might just save you from a scam.

Legal Repercussions

Ignorance is no excuse in the eyes of the law. So, having this knowledge up your sleeve? Priceless.

Real-World Examples

Agreement Scenarios

Let's say you and a colleague agree to share the cost of lunch. That's an agreement.

Contract Scenarios

Sign up for a new internet connection with a year's commitment? That, dear reader, is a contract.

Examples of Contracts vs. Informal Agreements

To crystallize the distinctions, here are some common examples of recognized contracts compared to informal agreements:

Contracts

•  Employment contracts 
•  Real estate purchase agreements
•  Business partnership agreements  
•  Vendor service contracts 
•  Commercial leases
•  Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs)
•  Insurance policies

Informal Agreements

•  Verbal promises 
•  Letters of intent
•  Handshake deals
•  "Gentlemen's agreements"
•  Email exchanges 

While even casual written agreements may look like contracts, important technicalities separate enforceable deals from informal ones.

Key Takeaways on Contracts vs. Agreements

Here are some key lessons on differentiating contracts and agreements:

•  Contracts must contain elements like offer, acceptance, consideration, and intent to be legally enforceable.
• 
  
•  Agreements rely more heavily on continued mutual consent rather than judicial enforcement.
• 
  
•  Certain types of contracts require written documentation under the Statute of Fraud.
• 
  
•  Proving contracts in court has a lower evidentiary burden than less formal agreements. 
• 
  
•  Contracts allow recovery of damages and other judicial remedies if breached.
• 
  
•  Well-structured contracts provide the greatest protection and predictability in business dealings.

Conclusion

While they may seem like mere semantics, understanding the differences between contracts and agreements is crucial. Whether you're sealing a business deal or just making plans with a friend, it's always good to know where you stand. Stay informed, and you'll surely stay ahead.

In sum, all contracts are agreements, but not all agreements exhibit the offering, acceptance, consideration, and intent required to be judicially binding contracts. Understanding the nuances of enforceability helps craft relationships with suitable levels of formality.

Common Contract vs. Agreement Questions 

Still, have some lingering questions? Here are answers to a few frequent issues:

Are verbal agreements ever enforceable?

They can be, but the burden of proof is much higher without documentation, especially for contracts involving goods/services over $500 per the Statute of Frauds. Written contracts always provide the best evidence and protections.

Can informal written agreements like MOUs and LOIs act as contracts?

Not necessarily. Many written agreements are still non-binding depending on wording and disclaimer clauses. But some may contain enforceable contractual language, so review them carefully.

Should business partnerships be formalized in a contract?

Yes, absolutely. Partnership agreements outline rights, responsibilities, profit sharing, decision-making, etc. Much harder to enforce expectations without contractual formalities.

Can you amend a contract without agreement from all parties?

No, changes require mutual consent, known as a "meeting of the minds". Unilateral amendments are not enforceable as they lack acceptance by all parties.

Can I break a contract if both parties agree?

Yes, contracts can be modified or terminated if both parties consent.

What happens if I breach an agreement?

It depends on the nature of the agreement. If it’s a contract, legal penalties might apply.

Is a written agreement the same as a contract?

Not always. It needs certain elements to be considered a contract.

Why are contracts important in business?

They provide security, and clarity, and set clear expectations for all involved parties.